The British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) has raised doubts over the reliability of data used to support claims that Christians are being systematically persecuted in Nigeria.
The narrative of widespread religious persecution gained momentum following Vice President Kashim Shettima’s address at the recent United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), where he described the humanitarian crisis in Gaza as “heart-wrenching” and called for a two-state solution to ensure Palestinian independence.
In the wake of Shettima’s remarks, U.S. television host Bill Maher described the situation in Nigeria as a “genocide,” while Senator Ted Cruz alleged that the Nigerian government was enabling a “massacre” of Christians.
Cruz, in a widely shared post on X, claimed that “50,000 Christians have been killed since 2009, 2,000 schools and 18,000 churches destroyed,” accusing the government of “looking the other way.”
Following these claims, U.S. President Donald Trump redesignated Nigeria as a Country of Particular Concern, a label reserved for nations accused of tolerating religious persecution.
In a subsequent post on Truth Social, Trump cited a report by Open Doors that claimed 3,100 Christians were killed in Nigeria between October 2023 and October 2024.
Read Also: Akpabio Denies Mocking Trump Over Alleged Christian Genocide
However, the same Open Doors report also documented 2,320 Muslim deaths during the same period and noted that groups labeled as “Fulani Terror Groups” were responsible for nearly one-third of Christian fatalities.
Responding to the BBC, Frans Veerman, a senior research fellow at Open Doors, explained that “Christians are still targeted, but increasingly some Muslims are also being attacked by Fulani militants.”
The BBC’s investigation revealed that many of the statistics frequently cited by Cruz and other campaigners, including claims of over 100,000 Christian deaths and the destruction of 18,000 churches since 2009, could not be independently verified.
Most of these figures were traced to reports by the International Society for Civil Liberties and Rule of Law (InterSociety), a Nigerian non-governmental organisation that monitors human rights abuses.
According to the BBC, InterSociety’s data collection methods were “opaque” and lacked verifiable sources.
The organisation reportedly combines summary figures from older publications with new estimates, making independent verification “nearly impossible.”
The report further noted that while Christians have indeed been victims of attacks, the majority of casualties from jihadist violence in Nigeria have been Muslims, a finding that challenges the claim of a targeted Christian genocide.
Nigeria’s federal government has consistently rejected allegations of religious persecution, describing them as “a gross misrepresentation of reality.” Officials maintain that extremist violence affects citizens of all faiths, driven by insecurity and criminality rather than religious motives.
Security experts quoted by the BBC echoed this view, noting that Nigeria’s conflict landscape includes multiple dimensions — insurgency, banditry, and communal clashes, rather than a single faith-based campaign.
While Trump has threatened unspecified action against Nigeria over the alleged “killing of Christians,” the BBC’s findings suggest that the data behind such claims may be deeply flawed.
